Summary
Jules, a German, and Jim, a Frenchman, are two writers who strike up a
close friendship. They share a passion for literature, art... and
women. After a trip to Greece, where they study a statue of a woman with
an enchanting smile, they return to France and meet Catherine, who seems
to have the same alluring smile. Both men are attracted towards the
young woman, but it is Jules she decides to marry. Then World War
I intervenes and all three are separated. After the war, Jules rejoins
Catherine and they live, with their young daughter Sabine, in a remote
mountain chalet in Germany. They invite Jim to stay with them for
a while. When he arrives, Jim notices that Jules and Catherine’s
marriage is disintegrating and that his own passion for Catherine has been
rekindled...
Review
Widely acknowledged as a masterpiece and probably the most popular of the New Wave French films
of the early 1960s, Jules et Jim is François Truffaut’s enchanting
ode to love and friendship. Based on an obscure novel by Henri-Pierre
Roché, the film depicts a 30 year long relationship involving two
men, Jules and Jim, and their shared lover, Catherine.
At the time, this was quite
a daring film, because it questioned some of the basic assumptions about
human relationships and offered a vision of an alternative kind of relationship.
That love and friendship can be reconciled is one of the most profound
statements the film makes, although the strains and problems that can create
are reflected with astonishing lucidity in the film.
The character of Catherine
must have seemed quite daring as well. Although she is enchanting
(as much through her intelligence as through her good looks), she is also
dangerously unpredictable and flighty. When her two male friends
exclude her from a discussion about Strindberg she throws herself into
the River Seine. When Jim tells her that she intends to marry another
woman, she pulls a gun on him. She even disappears with another man
after having given birth to her daughter.
Catherine is the consummate
free spirit, an extreme representation of the modern woman, constantly
fighting for equality with her male counterparts. Yet, whilst yielding
to these mad impulses, she harbours a need for love and security, which
she hopes to find in Jules. Unfortunately Jules cannot satisfy her
passion for adventure. The two can never be reconciled and in the
end she destroys everything, even the beautiful friendship of Jules and
Jim which has offered her sanctuary.
The film is beautifully realised
and must represent Truffaut’s greatest achievement. The playfulness
of the three central characters is reflected in some equally playful and
imaginative photography and editing. The film is replete with many of the
cinematographic devices associated with the New Wave directors: freeze-frames,
jump-cuts, expansive camera movements (often swirling to give a dizzying
a roundabout impression).
Partly out of necessity (to
reduce the film to an acceptable length), Truffaut employs some very aggressive,
tight editing, which makes the first half of the film incredibly fast moving
and deliciously entertaining. The pace slows in the latter half as
we are drawn into the intimacy of the love triangle. This is where
Truffaut shows his true genius as a director, evoking some remarkable performances
from his actors as he draws out the interminable human dilemmas which the
situation creates.
Raould Coutard's beautiful
and fluid photography is accompanied by an equally beautiful and evocative
score from Georges Delerue (a favourite of the New Wave directors).
Both the images and the music capture the subtle changes in mood to almost
devastating effect.
In the role of Catherine,
Jeanne Moreau is unremittingly brilliant. The part could have been
written for her – it exudes a curious blend of strong-minded independence
yet childlike vulnerability that suits the actress perfectly. As
the impulsive femme fatale she is totally bewitching, but it is her scenes
where she displays emotional insecurity that are the most poignant and
engaging. She sings Cyrus Bazziak’s “Le Tourbillon de la
vie” as if it were the theme of her life. (Bazziak himself appears
in the film as Catherine’s third lover, Albert.)
Jules and Jim are
played respectively by the celebrated Austrian stage actor Oskar Werner
and the French actor Henri Serre, both comparatively unknown in France
at the time. Truffaut cast Werner having been impressed with his
performance in Max Ophül’s film Lola Montès and would
cast him in a lead role in his later film Farenheit 451. Truffaut
chose Serre mainly for his physical resemblance to the young Henri-Pierre
Roché – tall and thin, with a deep but gentle voice.
After the commercial failure
of his previous film, Tirez sur le pianiste, Truffaut was compelled
to make Jules and Jim on a modest budget (often using his friends’
homes for the location scenes). He was also determined that this
should be a successful film - without another success he would find it
difficult to finance future films. As a result, he tuned his film
to the tastes of the public to a greater extent than his New Wave contemporaries
would ever countenance. The ploy paid off. But even Truffaut
could not have imagined the extent of the success the film would enjoy.
Despite being initially banned
in Italy and receiving an over-18 classification in France, Jules et
Jim quickly became a popular and successful film, across Europe and
in the United States. It also unleashed something of a merchandising
phenomenon, with Jules and Jim souvenirs suddenly hitting the shops
(caps, tee-shirts, etc.). The film not only secured François
Truffaut’s position as one of the most highly regarded directors of his
generation but it also made Jeanne Moreau an international star.
Today, the film is often
referred to and held up as a prime example of New Wave cinema. It
is a film that cannot fail to leave its audience unmoved. This is
a uniquely perceptive and uncompromising film about life - the comedy and
the tragedy, mixed together in the turbulent whirlpool of life.
© James Travers 2002
See also:
The life of François Truffaut
Les 400 coups
Tirez sur le pianiste
Farenheit 451
Baisers volés
Le Dernier métro
Buy films by François Truffaut
More about the French New Wave
|